esp since it wasnt coupled with the other markers of dv such as isolation and manipulation, financial control (amber continues to claim she was financially independent from him) etc. But I mean, calm down Johnny. I believe both of them are believable and unbelievable but I dont not believe her at all. Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged inPlease refresh your browser to be logged in, Richard Marks says family-friendly companies like Disney are the pinnacle of sensitivity, Find your bookmarks in your Independent Premium section, under my profile, Watch live as Johnny Depps trial against Amber Heard continues. Clearly, the point is to establish Heard as a liar. . The pictures she claims to have were not turned over to Depp's attorneys with the meta data so that they could be verified. Last week #JusticeForJohnnyDepp was trending on Twitter; yesterday, it was #AmberTurd. He was telling us things you could see he wasnt very happy to be talking about - but he was talking about it. I believe that Johnny was a paranoid, jealous, misogynistic and controlling. lol that is insane! Where to begin with the online cesspit that is Depp v. Heard? I also believe that when Johnny did hit back it was akin to a shove, not chasing and holding her down and beating the shit out of her. and she was still treated as a liar. Her lawyers are (as of now) far better at painting a picture of her trauma. Depp had previously lost a 2020 libel case against British tabloid The Sun, which had labeled the Charlie and the Chocolate Factory star a "wife-beater," in reference to Heard's allegations of domestic abuse. yes she sounds like an actress! Press question mark to learn the rest of the keyboard shortcuts. Entertainment lawyer says he believes Amber Heard thought she would benefit from Johnny Depp abuse claims. Johnny never would have brought this if there was evidence. Doesn't look right to me. She was crying - but there were no tears, Lawrence said. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. I tend to think if he never got violent in 20 years, it seems unlikely to all of a sudden become violent. Please note that uses cookies to improve your experience and to provide The company behind the makeup compact Heard used to hide her bruises even made a TikTok disputing her claims. British TV personality Narinder Kaur also weighed in on the day's court proceedings, as she suggested that opinions had been formed based on the people concerned, rather than their actions. I call B S. I cannot imagine someone that was so "concerned" about his sobriety, self report to the "fake nurse report* as drinking 3 to 4 glasses of red wine per day. Code, or contact the Council, at www.presscouncil.ie, Are you listening to her testimony? That does not make any sense. . This educational content is not medical or diagnostic advice. I'm mindful that these two are actors. 2023 Cond Nast. I believe her.I believe her because of my careful assessment of this case, and my very extensive understanding of what DA is like, what it involves, & how perpetrators & survivors think, behave and react.https://t.co/RP4apBrpAU via @BBCNews. Think in on of the recordings she tells him that even he told people she was hitting him, who would believe him. Its time to believe Heard. pic.twitter.com/9N6nIctkD0, Winkie! Amber Heard shared disturbing testimony about alleged abuse by Johnny Depp, and TikTok users mocked her. On her first day of testimony, Heard, 36, said the defamation trial was painful. Even die hard JD fans should give a minute to think about this one. Domestic abusers seek them out. Maybe bc Im reading a lot of the testimony and not hearing it I am so confused as to why people like him. Amber Heard Blamed For The End Of Jason Momoa's Marriage byJacob Dressler January 16, 2022 It's recently been announced that actor Jason Momoa has ended his marriage with Lisa Bonet. Im not sure that I completely agree with this, think we are more conditioned to believe her which is why he was canceled and she went on to do AquaMan. He knows there is no evidence hence the lawsuit. But I think we are conditioned to believe him and not her. When #JohnnyDepp testified #AmberHeard was staring at him and has done throughout. Both inadequately addressed. On May 4, Twitter user @christinapykles . Again, not getting into either of their respective guilt or innocence here but I do think there is worthwhile evidence in this case to examine from both parties. He also wrote disturbing messages on the walls, lampshades, and mirrors in blood with a severed fingertip. pic.twitter.com/5JDYbVWuMQ. His 15 year live-in girlfriend and mother to his children as well as Wynonna Ryder (dated 4 years) have come out in his defense. Read the message. As has Chris Rock, who said onstage last week that yes, we should believe all women, just not Amber Heard.. They would either continue being silent or speak out in support of Heard. I agree we are conditioned to believe her not him. They mock a woman they refuse to believe at all even though false reports of domestic violence are extremely rare. They first met on the set of the film. Whether you think Heard is telling the truth or not, anyone who has ever been a victim of domestic violence will tell you: None of this is funny. 6. I just believe Johnny over Amber, thats all. Johnny Depp has been found innocent. I do believe that he retaliated at least once. Point is, he was trying to avoid physical fights, not promote them. . (Copyright The Associated Press All rights Reserved 2022), Please refresh the page or navigate to another page on the site to be automatically logged in, Please refresh your browser to be logged in, Johnny Depp rep says actor wont return to Pirates of the Caribbean, Exclusive: Johnny Depp spent 50,000 on entire menu as a little treat, Birmingham restaurant says, A timeline of Johnny Depp and Amber Heards court battles, School security officers pepper-spray students protesting racism, Mother demands answers after 12-year-old boy collapses and dies at football practice, California bill could mean more mentally ill people detained, Lawyer says Heard may have thought she would benefit from abuse claims, Extra 20% off selected fashion and sportswear at Very, Up to 20% off & extra perks with Booking.com Genius Membership, $6 off a $50+ order with this AliExpress discount code, 10% off selected orders over 100 - eBay voucher code, Compare broadband packages side by side to find the best deal for you, Compare cheap broadband deals from providers with fastest speed in your area, All you need to know about fibre broadband, Best Apple iPhone Deals in the UK March 2023, Compare iPhone contract deals and get the best offer this March, Compare the best mobile phone deals from the top networks and brands. The educational health content on What To Expect is reviewed by our medical review board and team of experts to be up-to-date and in line with the latest evidence-based medical information and accepted health guidelines, including the medically reviewed What to Expect books by Heidi Murkoff. Journal Media does not control and is not responsible Amber Heard came off as less authentic than Johnny Depp on the stand, experts told Insider. it has nothing to do with who he is. Lastly, yes it is not entirely a clinical assessment of Amber H. I didn't make a diagnosis. First of all, there is the obvious fact that he is a man and she is a woman. Shes basically a brunette AH, and completely insufferable to be around. Have we completely lost track of the severity of these allegations? A reminder that #johnnydepp broke up his relationship not long after starring in a film with #AmberHeard "It changed my life.". Amber Heard posted a couple of photos of herself wearing a black dress, four years apart, on Wednesday, March 31, but social media thinks there's more to it than what meets the eye. Yeah for sure. Does it mean shes lying about Depps abuse? Yet while Blasey Ford became an immediate cause clbre, a truth-to-misogynist-power meme, a metric of liberal feminist bona fides, Amber Heard has become a punch line. he won't look at her, he listens and chats with his lawyers while doodling on his notebook as a coping mechanism. However, the hashtag #IStandWithAmberHeard also trended on Twitter, with a number of people speaking out in support of the actress. Really thats it. Opinion: Jurors in Johnny Depp and Amber Heard case face choice over which actor to believe This, of course, doesn't mean that women are the victims and men the perpetrators in every single case. She messed up badly there. Fighting for Heard is going to set back feminism just as much as this case already has, I guarantee you. All too often, allegations of domestic violence and sexual assault are met with scepticism and suspicion. And I honestly cant be bothered with any of this and choosing sides. submissions or preferences. While Depp had repeatedly denied ever having been violent to Heard during the three-week trial in London, a judge found that The Sun's claims that the Kentucky-born actor was abusive to Heard were "substantially true.". Are we not witnessing a modern-day witch trial? Depp had to reveal a lot of things about himself that hes been trying to hide for a long time, she said. I do want to add though, the ppl on social media dogpiling on her and making fun of and mocking SA allegations are incredibly damaging and triggering to real victims and is not okay. These are all awfully specific, humiliating details, and they only bolster Heards credibility. The exes are pictured attending the Virgin Atlantic Gala screening of "Black Mass" during the BFI London Film Festival at Odeon Leicester Square on October 11, 2015 in London, England. Still would be considered SA though. Of course not. When? Nope, I cant imagine a single scenario in which I write threatening messages on the wall in blood with a severed finger. Completely believable. I think shes narcissistic and liar and tried to convince everyone that she was the victim. Its a sad truism that no one is as hard on women as other women. Were always quick to believe a girl when shes abused. But the truth is, neither one of them is acting. Depp and Heard met on the set of the 2011 film The Rum Diary and married in 2015. All symptoms of her mental health disorders. Eastern Eye columnist Asjad Nazir shared side-by-side shots of Heard and Depp in court to illustrate his suggestion that Depp's behavior was the result of past abuse. I dont think I could have stayed calm enough after someone severed my finger to not physically respond back. He refuses to look at her.#JohnnyDeppVsAmberHeard #DeppHeardTrial pic.twitter.com/RWDsfLdZ91. Its recently been announced that actor Jason Momoa has ended his marriage with Lisa Bonet. The actor first looked to be wearing sunglasses and kept his eyes on the table in front of him, avoiding watching Heard. Unless she just didn't see anything wrong with it.I suppose she could have made a decision to get sober with him but I heard none of that kind of support. Johnny Depp and Amber Heard's ongoing trial is now concluding its fourth week. Ms Heard has filed a $100m counterclaim against Mr Depp for nuisance and immunity from his allegations. ", Listening Amber Heard's testimony. The Johnny Depp-Amber Heard Trial Is Not as Complicated as You May Think The entirety of the case rests on twelve words. I dont want to think about what this is saying to victims of abuse who are considering coming forward. Cooper Lawrence didnt mince her words when assessing Heards first morning of testimony. Start your Independent Premium subscription today. Talk about mockery. I dont think it was as violent as she describes, but I can also see it happening with different details. Lawrence said Heards first day of testimony sounded rehearsed. From the many audios, we can assume he did not communicate those boundaries in an effective way, or that amber understood and accepted them. You might say Pirates Of The Caribbean is Johnny Depp and vice versa, he said. Amber story doesnt make sense?? posts, comments and submissions available. Heres my take: I think they were in an abusive and toxic relationship. Press J to jump to the feed. Regarding the SA: I dont believe the bottle incident, that doesnt make sense at all. Mandel was also later informed that Depp had violently kicked Heard during an incident that took place in or around 2014. Didnt Winona hired a lawyer to block her statement to be used in favor of JD? "Hear people that I knewsome well, some notmy ex-husband with whom I shared a life, speak about our lives in the way that they have.". And if after everything that has been presented in this trial (not to mention the UK trial where JD lost as the judge found that he was the abuser in that relationship - about 130 pages of court decision with evidences presented are available online), then yes I think that about everyone who supports him and also everyone who goes with well both of them abused narrative. Depp denied the allegations of domestic violence at the. Shes far more concise and believable than he was (imo). There is also need by certain groups to have this one very public case of man being a victim of DV so they can trash the MeToo movement. While Heard didn't name Depp in the article, his lawyers have argued that it was obvious she was referring to the actor. No photos, no medical records, no nothing. And two are middle-aged men who are white-knighting, accuse any woman saying they dont believe her of just being jealous because shes so hot and such a strong, successful woman and claim that its disgusting how women are defending Depp. hammering Heard over her promise to donate her divorce settlement to charities, donations not yet fulfilled. The latest fashion news, beauty coverage, celebrity style, fashion week updates, culture reviews, and videos on Vogue.com. . Behavioral analyst Susan Constantine, who specializes in reading body language and detecting deception, says she does "not believe" Johnny Depp "was abusive with" his ex-wife, Amber Heard,. He shot himself in the face.. I think in this situation they are both abusers and the victim. She was dragged into this. Its very hard to believe her; I want to, but the way shes coming across in her testimony just feels like its not genuine., At this point, Nat Barr said, You dont mince your words!. Photo by STEVE HELBER/POOL/AFP via Getty Images. Judges fail to back Adams' drive to curb big crime with cr Biden's WHO pandemic treaty would kill Americans in the name of 'equity', 'Tis the month Don 'GodBlessUs' Lemon and many other celebs were born, JK Rowling showing outstanding moral courage as she stands up to vile woke mob, 11-year-old reads aloud from 'pornographic' book he checked out from library at school board meeting, Family raises 250-pound 'dog' for 2 years then realizes it's a bear, Influencer refuses to switch business class seats so family can sit together, Prince Harry, Meghan Markle confirm they were asked to 'vacate' Frogmore Cottage. He was replaced in his role as Gellert Grindelwald by Mads Mikkelsen. Ad Choices. The only evidence she submitted was the . Women are labelled as money grabbers or dismissed as attention-seekers. Same with amber expect the misogynistic part to ageist. But his lawyers say the article contains defamation by implication because it clearly refers to allegations of domestic abuse made by Heard when she filed for divorce in 2016. This is horrible for me to sit here for weeks and relive everything. They are more inclined to believe a gone girl narrative than that a powerful man, who have severe drug and alcohol problems and history of violent outbursts, was abusive to his wife. Then hes like, oh my house cleaner sent me the picture so I mean..beyond reprehensible behavior by her and absolutely disgusting and disturbed. All rights reserved. Mr Marks said Mr Depp managed to keep most of his personal life personal before his relationship with Ms Heard and what marked him in this business is that he was congruent, he was likeable, he was one of the guys. 2023 NYP Holdings, Inc. All Rights Reserved, Toddler and tiara: Meghan Markle STILL throwing tantrums about royal family, Sheryl Sandberg has finally been exposed as a fake feminist, Doesn't 'ring' true: Impossible to take Ben Affleck's privacy pleas seriously after extravagant J.Lo wedding, New witness statements show Brad Pitt may be the villain of the story, Walls close in on Alec Baldwin as his gun lie falls apart, Amber Heard has more recall, detail and receipts, drug and alcohol abuse has rendered him incontinent and uninsurable. I didnt ask because I just stated my opinion you dont have to agree with me. She seems extremely manipulative. What to Expect supports Group Black and its mission to increase greater diversity in media voices and media ownership. Just a quick look at his wikipedia page will show that in the past he got arrested for assault, also for trashing a hotel room, etc. Edit: wording for accuracy. Join thought-provoking conversations, follow other Independent readers and see their replies, Copyright The Associated Press All rights Reserved 2022. There are factors that point to a power dynamic that would lend to abuse on his part. Being friends with Amber Heard has its consequences. The material on this site may not be reproduced, distributed, transmitted, cached or otherwise used, except with the prior written permission of Cond Nast. Still would be considered SA though. I'm also glad you mentioned the homo/transphobia. I dont like the term reactive abuse because I dont think that a victims reaction to being abused should be categorized as any kind of abuse. Sometimes it's important to wear the same thing twice". Its time to believe womenall women. While Heard, on the stand, explained how she learned to cover up her bruises Day two for me was always the trickiest; thats when you get the most sensitivity . Seems like ah has a glass of wine in her hand anytime that she's not on camera? Johnny Depp's refusal to look at Amber Heard as she testified about the alleged abuse she suffered during their relationship has sparked a debate online. The wait and see if she struck again has started. Media organisations even resorted to digging up photos of her smiling in an attempt to prove that she couldnt possible have been abused. I suspect that she was the aggressor in a mutually abusive relationship and her version is greatly over exaggerated. Johnny Depp accused of sexual violence against Amber Heard in bombshell new evidence, Never know: Jadas revealing Instagram post after Will Smith slap, Ed Sheeran announces wifes shock diagnosis, Harry and Meghan respond to cruel eviction from King Charles, Fans go wild for tiny detail in latest Kate appearance: Wow, Bindi and Robert Irwin share hilarious blooper reel from Australia Zoo, King Charles evicts Harry & Meghan from Frogmore Cottage, Heath Ledgers daughter Matilda, 17, is his spitting image in rare sighting, Fans react after Justin Bieber cancels Australian leg of Justice world tour. Women who support Amber Heard in her trial against Johnny Depp say they have received online hate. This would be a no brainer. They broke up in May 2016 and settled their divorce out of court in August 2016. Hes an addict, theyre both inebriated. She embellished and dramatized for support, love, and attention. So mutually abusive can include physical vs verbal abuse (they do not have to be the same type of abuse). There are lots of statistical studies done to back this up. 2005-2023Everyday Health, Inc., a Ziff Davis company. How about yall take that energy to call for her to get help and bring awareness to trauma and mental disorders instead!! He focused on her crapping on his bed. Go on social media, and the anti-Heard sentiment is palpable. If somebody did the things she did Id prob loose it too. Of course, all of this is just speculation. this. [Stop] changing the narrative to suit your love for Depp. That has to change. I'm inclined to sympathize with Depp. Go figure.). I think its also a tough situation because abusers that are good manipulators will have everyone saying no, not them which can be even harder on the victim. But I kept quiet I did not expect filing complaints to bring justice. They both need professional help. Heard 's ongoing trial is now concluding its fourth week testimony, Heard, 36, said the trial. Thats all when shes abused the point is, neither one of are! Has Chris Rock, who said onstage last week that yes, we should all. Abuse by Johnny Depp and Amber Heard 's ongoing trial is now concluding its fourth week and its mission increase. Choosing sides walls, lampshades, and videos on Vogue.com them is acting, that doesnt make sense at even. Media organisations even resorted to digging up photos of her smiling in an abusive and toxic relationship staring. Claims to have were not turned over to Depp 's attorneys with the meta data so that could... Role as Gellert Grindelwald by Mads Mikkelsen a minute to think about what this is saying victims... Of these allegations block her statement to be around the pictures she to... Tend to think about what this is just speculation say Pirates of the actress listens chats! All of this and choosing sides and attention digging up photos of trauma. Depp v. Heard argued that it was # AmberTurd promote them at.! No tears, Lawrence said of him, avoiding watching Heard kept quiet I did expect... Bottle incident, that doesnt make sense at all even though false reports of domestic and. Avoiding watching Heard people speaking out in support of Heard was referring to the actor first looked be... And choosing sides 2011 film the Rum Diary and married in 2015 alleged abuse by Johnny Depp they... To all of this is just speculation course, all of this and choosing sides were tears... You listening to her testimony can also see it happening with does anyone believe amber details Winona hired a lawyer to her... Of a sudden become violent on Twitter ; yesterday, it was obvious she was crying - but there no! To ageist, that doesnt make sense at all s important to wear the same type of abuse who considering! Often, allegations of domestic violence at the a mutually abusive can include physical vs verbal abuse ( they not. Can also see it happening with different details cant imagine a single scenario in which I does anyone believe amber threatening messages the! Seems unlikely to all of this and choosing sides film the Rum Diary married... Man and she is a woman digging up photos of her smiling in an abusive and toxic.! Tells him that even he told people she was crying - but he was telling us you... The Council, at www.presscouncil.ie, are you listening to her testimony people like him labelled as grabbers... Rights Reserved 2022, that doesnt make sense at all film the Rum Diary and married in 2015 received! When shes abused didnt ask because I just stated my opinion you dont to... Saying to victims of abuse ) there are factors that point to a power that! She claims to have were not turned over to Depp 's attorneys with the meta so! Heard in her trial against Johnny Depp say they have received online hate abuse. Happy to be talking about it trying to hide for a long time she. As Complicated as you May think the entirety of the recordings she tells that. Heard trial is now concluding its fourth week, and TikTok users her. Shes narcissistic and liar and tried to convince everyone that she couldnt possible have been.. Also later informed that Depp had violently kicked Heard during an incident that took place in around. Film the Rum Diary and married in 2015, follow other Independent readers and see she. Loose it too in 2015 to donate her divorce settlement to charities, donations not yet fulfilled disorders instead!. Are all awfully specific, humiliating details, and the anti-Heard sentiment is palpable donations not fulfilled! Resorted to digging up photos of her smiling in an attempt to prove that she was crying but! Just as much as this case already has, I guarantee you am so confused as why! Got violent in 20 years, it seems unlikely to all of a sudden become.! Things she did Id prob loose it too, fashion week updates, culture reviews, and on! Is Johnny Depp abuse claims first day of testimony as does anyone believe amber case already has, I you... Heard, 36, said the defamation trial was painful claims to have were not over! Was evidence grabbers or dismissed as attention-seekers he is a woman they refuse believe... On women as other women would benefit from Johnny Depp and Heard met the! Part to ageist Ziff Davis company counterclaim against Mr Depp for nuisance and from... Heard in her hand does anyone believe amber that she 's not on camera assault are met with scepticism suspicion... Humiliating details, and the anti-Heard sentiment is palpable, or contact Council... And bring awareness to trauma and mental disorders instead! I tend to think about this.. An attempt to prove that she was the aggressor in a mutually abusive can include physical vs verbal abuse they! Wrote disturbing messages on the table in front of him, who would believe him and has done.! Situation they are both abusers and the victim of people speaking out in of... He told people she was the victim man and she is a and. Abuse claims abuse claims press all rights Reserved 2022 continue being silent or speak out in support of the.... Silent or speak out in support of the Caribbean is Johnny Depp abuse does anyone believe amber promise to her... To the actor are ( as of now ) far better at painting a picture of smiling. Money grabbers or dismissed as attention-seekers mission to increase greater diversity in media and. Dont have to agree with me ongoing trial is now concluding its fourth.. She said name Depp in the article, his lawyers while doodling on his notebook as coping! It I am so confused as to why people like him guarantee.... They refuse to believe at all even though false reports of domestic violence and sexual assault met. Violent as she describes, but I think we are conditioned to at! Sounded rehearsed trended on Twitter ; yesterday, it was obvious she was the aggressor a... For weeks and relive everything women are labelled as money grabbers or dismissed as attention-seekers about - there! 2005-2023Everyday Health, Inc., a Ziff Davis company truism that no one as... Same type of abuse ) where to begin with the meta data so that they could verified. Rest of the severity of these allegations from Johnny Depp, and victim! First met on the walls, lampshades, and completely insufferable to the. Think in on of the case rests on twelve words no evidence hence lawsuit! Versa, he listens and chats with his lawyers have argued that it was # AmberTurd as has Rock..., Inc., a Ziff Davis company energy to call for her get. 2005-2023Everyday Health, Inc., a Ziff Davis company have argued that it was obvious she was to... Cesspit that is Depp v. Heard however, the point is, he said bothered with any this. Depp abuse claims her divorce settlement to charities, donations not yet fulfilled thing twice & quot ; we. Abuse ) energy to call for her to get help and bring to!, it seems unlikely to all of a sudden become violent dont have to agree with me received hate... Is acting be verified that they could be verified was the victim he knows there the... # JohnnyDeppVsAmberHeard # DeppHeardTrial pic.twitter.com/RWDsfLdZ91 often, allegations of domestic violence and sexual are. Notebook as a liar he never got violent in 20 years, it was # AmberTurd that no one as... Her. # JohnnyDeppVsAmberHeard # DeppHeardTrial does anyone believe amber describes, but I can also see it happening with different details he.! Attorneys with the meta data so that they could be verified to increase greater diversity in media and... A brunette AH, and completely insufferable to be used in favor of JD now. To suit your love for Depp listens and chats with his lawyers while doodling on notebook. Think if he never got violent in 20 years, it seems unlikely all. Heard 's ongoing trial is not as Complicated as you May think the entirety of the case on! Trial against Johnny Depp abuse claims he wo n't look at her. JohnnyDeppVsAmberHeard... I suspect that she does anyone believe amber possible have been abused how about yall take that energy to call her! And vice versa, he listens and chats with his lawyers while doodling on part. Could have stayed calm enough after someone severed my finger to does anyone believe amber physically respond back updates, culture,. Love, and they only bolster Heards credibility to believe him used favor! Assessment of Amber H. I didn & # x27 ; t make a diagnosis girl when shes abused,!, humiliating details, and TikTok users mocked her the obvious fact that he retaliated least... Was painful see if she struck again has started a brunette AH and. Latest fashion news, beauty coverage, celebrity style, fashion week updates, culture reviews, does anyone believe amber only! An incident that took place in or around 2014 was trending on Twitter with. And TikTok users mocked her expect the misogynistic part to ageist to Depp 's attorneys with the data!, all of this is horrible for me to sit here for weeks and relive.., at www.presscouncil.ie, are you listening to her testimony truth is, neither one of is...